The Principles of Representative GovernmentCambridge University Press, 1997 M02 28 The thesis of this original and provocative book is that representative government should be understood as a combination of democratic and undemocratic, aristocratic elements. Professor Manin challenges the conventional view that representative democracy is no more than an indirect form of government by the people, in which citizens elect representatives only because they cannot assemble and govern in person. The argument is developed by examining the historical moments when the present institutional arrangements were chosen from among the then available alternatives. Professor Manin reminds us that while today representative institutions and democracy appear as virtually indistinguishable, when representative government was first established in Europe and America, it was designed in opposition to democracy proper. Drawing on the procedures used in earlier republican systems, from classical Athens to Renaissance Florence, in order to highlight the alternatives that were forsaken, Manin brings to the fore the generally overlooked results of representative mechanisms. These include the elitist aspect of elections and the non-binding character of campaign promises. |
Contents
The triumph of election | |
The principle of distinction | |
apuretheory The two faces ofelection the benefits ofambiguity Election andthe principles of modern natural right | |
Metamorphoses of representative government | |
Index | |
Common terms and phrases
andthe AntiFederalists appointed argument aristocratic Aristotle Assembly asthe Athenian democracy Athens betweenthe bylot bythe candidates centuriate assemblies century characteristics choice choose citizens classes cleavages concept consent Constitution Corporatism Council culture debate decisionmaking decisions democratic didnot discussion distinction distribution effect egalitarian election electoral elites established expression favor Federalist Florentine freedom fromthe functions Guicciardini Hansen Harrington Ibid individuals institutions inthe isnot itis itwas Madison magistracies magistrates Melancton Smith modern Montesquieu natural aristocracy ofelection ofpolitical ofrepresentative ofthe oftheir onthe opinion Parliament parliamentarianism particular party democracy person Philadelphia Convention political representation Polybius popular preferences prerogative principle procedure proposed propositions Protagoras qualification reason representative democracy representative government republic republican role rotation Rousseau rulers Schmitt Siéyès social suffrage superiority term thatis thatthe theAssembly TheAthenian theelective theelectorate thepeople thesame thosewho tobe tothe trait universal suffrage University Press vote voters wasnot wealth withthe